• Advertise
  • About us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact us
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Australian Times News
  • News
    • Weather
    • Sport
    • Technology
    • Business & Finance
      • Currency Zone
    • Lotto Results
      • The Lott
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
    • Horoscopes
    • Health & Wellness
    • Recipes
  • Travel
  • Expat Life
  • Move to Australia
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Weather
    • Sport
    • Technology
    • Business & Finance
      • Currency Zone
    • Lotto Results
      • The Lott
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
    • Horoscopes
    • Health & Wellness
    • Recipes
  • Travel
  • Expat Life
  • Move to Australia
No Result
View All Result
Australian Times News
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Before we introduce vaccine passports we need to know how they’ll be used

The use to which a vaccine passport might be put is key. Air New Zealand is interested in trans-Tasman travel, but without clear controls in place it seems very likely there will be pressure to expand reliance on them.

The Conversation by The Conversation
02-03-2021 22:30
in News
GettyImages

GettyImages

Tim Dare, University of Auckland

Air New Zealand is to trial digital “vaccine passports” on trans-Tasman routes in April. A media release says: “The goal is to enable customers to seamlessly manage their digital travel documentation throughout their travel experience.”

And it’s easy to see why. Airlines want people back in the air, the tourism industry wants them back in their hotels, restaurants and rental cars. And many of us have family and friends overseas — my daughter is having a baby in Melbourne in July and I want to visit!

The airline will be using the Travel Pass app offered by the International Air Transport Association (IATA), which it says has been “developed with the highest levels of data privacy and security”.

But vaccine passports bring significant risks. We should identify those risks and what we are going to do about them before wholesale introduction.

Unequal access to passports

The use to which a vaccine passport might be put is key. Air New Zealand is interested in trans-Tasman travel, but without clear controls in place it seems very likely there will be pressure to expand reliance on them.

Elsewhere we have seen suggestions they be used to control access to or participation in a range of places and activities with a risk of COVID transmission — sporting events, public venues, even workplaces.

AlsoRead...

How She Sells with Brooke helps thousands of women build new careers through high-ticket sales

How She Sells with Brooke helps thousands of women build new careers through high-ticket sales

6 October 2026
Mark Levin and Yael Eckstein: Celebrating 250 Years - The Bond Between America and Israel

Mark Levin and Yael Eckstein: Celebrating 250 Years – The Bond Between America and Israel

30 September 2026

Why would that matter? If they are good for airlines, wouldn’t they be good in other contexts, too? One reason to worry is that vaccines — and therefore vaccine passports — will not be available to everyone.

Some access issues are matters of global justice. The citizens of many countries will not have access to vaccines in the near future. As is often the case, people who are already disadvantaged will bear further burdens.

Who gets a passport first?

Perhaps this will seem all too remote and idealistic, but there will be domestic versions of these concerns too.

Some New Zealanders might be unable or unwilling to have COVID vaccines because of existing health conditions. On current roll-out plans, others will have to wait in line behind prioritised groups such as border, quarantine and health workers.

There will also be people who choose not to be vaccinated because of principled objections to vaccination, but we can perhaps put that group aside for the moment. Any disadvantage they suffer will at least have been willingly taken on.


So the significance of access to vaccination — and vaccine passports — will depend crucially on the limits placed on their use.

If it simply prevents people travelling to Australia, or makes such trips more burdensome, society might tolerate the discrimination unequal access will cause. If it affects people’s capacity to socialise, work or travel domestically, it will be a more serious issue.

How reliable will passports be?

Other potential risks flow from the fact a variety of vaccines will be available and new COVID strains will emerge regularly. If the vaccines are not all equally effective, or more infectious new variants of the virus affect their performance, how will vaccine passports reflect this?

We might assume vaccine passports give those relying on them — whether officials administering travel permissions or fellow passengers — evidence of the risk posed by a passport holder. But it may be that not all passport holders are equally immune.

If there are doubts a passport truly means its holder has had an effective vaccine or has immunity against some recent strain, the value of the passport diminishes. We may still have cause to worry about the risk posed by the person in the seat next to us.


As with any digital system, there will be privacy and information security issues too. Air New Zealand has described the proposed Travel Pass as “a place to store all your health credentials digitally in one place”.

It seems unlikely it would hold that much information — we haven’t achieved that with hospital-based electronic health records — and that would be a good thing.

A set of standards would no doubt address what information was held on the app and who it could be shared with. We should have those standards in place before we allow passports.

Hand applying sticker to vaccination certificate
Confirmation of vaccination being added to an International Certificate of Vaccination or Prophylaxis (ICVP), also known as the carte jaune or yellow card. GettyImages

New age, new risks

It has been pointed out that vaccine passports are not new: the World Health Organisation’s “yellow card”, an international certificate to record inoculations against yellow fever, cholera, typhus and smallpox has been around since the 1930s.

But it’s not clear what we should make of the example. The yellow card might pose significant ethical risk, too, if access to vaccines is unequal or there are concerns about the reliability of cards.

As serious as these diseases are, they are rare or endemic to certain areas: the scale of the COVID pandemic makes some ethical risks more likely and more pressing. Some of those risks flow from vaccine passports being proposed in a digital age, where information can be held and shared in ways unimaginable only a couple of decades ago.

Furthermore, the yellow card has the backing of international health regulations that specify conditions for validity.

No shared standards

Finally, vaccination passports seem likely to vary in an important way from the passports we know best. The value of regular passports rests on the shared international standards that lie behind them.

If I produce a valid passport, an immigration official knows I am a New Zealand citizen, that my identity has been confirmed, that my passport photo is a reasonable likeness, and so on.

There are no such shared standards for vaccine passports, so it is much less clear what can be assumed about the passport holder. The very thing that makes passports valuable might not be true of a vaccine passport.

The point here is not that vaccine passports are a bad idea. They might be an important part of managing COVID. But we should be clear about the risks such passports pose and about how we are going to manage those risks before they get a foot in the door.

Tim Dare, Professor of Philosophy, University of Auckland

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Tags: SB001
DMCA.com Protection Status

SUBSCRIBE to our NEWSLETTER

[mc4wp_form id=”2384248″]

Don't Miss

NRMA welcomes dogs at four NSW South Coast Holiday Parks

by Pauline Torongo
22 October 2026
NRMA welcomes dogs at four NSW South Coast Holiday Parks
Lifestyle

Pet-friendly stays and nearby beaches give families more coastal holiday options as Australian caravan and camping trips reach record levels.

Read moreDetails

How She Sells with Brooke helps thousands of women build new careers through high-ticket sales

by Pauline Torongo
6 October 2026
How She Sells with Brooke helps thousands of women build new careers through high-ticket sales
Business & Finance

More than 3,000 women have joined She Sells with Brooke Triplett to build careers in high-ticket sales. For many, the...

Read moreDetails

Qualities to look for in a Caribbean Luxury Cruise Experience

by Pauline Torongo
6 October 2026
Qualities to look for in a Caribbean Luxury Cruise Experience. Image: Supplied
Travel

Luxury Caribbean cruises are often associated with beaches, sunshine, and tropical ease, but they can be more than that with...

Read moreDetails

Mark Levin and Yael Eckstein: Celebrating 250 Years – The Bond Between America and Israel

by Pauline Torongo
30 September 2026
Mark Levin and Yael Eckstein: Celebrating 250 Years - The Bond Between America and Israel
News

As America marks 250 years since the Declaration of Independence, Yael Eckstein and Mark Levin explore the biblical values and...

Read moreDetails

How supporting Australia’s Care Workforce could strengthen care in the community

by Pauline Torongo
10 September 2026
How supporting Australia’s Care Workforce could strengthen care in the community
News

Australian care funding faces growing scrutiny after a 2025 ANAO report found NDIS losses from fraud, non-compliance, and payment errors...

Read moreDetails

The Future of Work Is Changing: What HR must champion next, according to Energy Collective Co

by Pauline Torongo
28 August 2026
What HR Must Champion Next, According to Energy Collective Co
Business & Finance

Energy Collective Co examines the root causes of performance by considering how work is designed, how leadership is enacted and...

Read moreDetails

From Empathy Burnout to Body-Led Recovery: What Heidi Jane of Intuition Co. learned by living through what she teaches

by Pauline Torongo
25 August 2026
What Heidi Jane of Intuition Co. learned by living through what she teaches
Lifestyle

Recognising emotional exhaustion is only the first step. While supportive habits such as rest, time in nature, hydration, and reduced...

Read moreDetails
Load More

Copyright © Blue Sky Publications Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
australiantimes.co.uk is a division of Blue Sky Publications Ltd. Reproduction without permission prohibited. DMCA.com Protection Status

  • About us
  • Write for Us
  • Advertise
  • Contact us
  • T&Cs, Privacy and GDPR
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Weather
    • Sport
    • Technology
    • Business & Finance
      • Currency Zone
    • Lotto Results
      • The Lott
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
    • Horoscopes
    • Health & Wellness
    • Recipes
  • Travel
  • Expat Life
  • Move to Australia

Copyright © Blue Sky Publications Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
australiantimes.co.uk is a division of Blue Sky Publications Ltd. Reproduction without permission prohibited. DMCA.com Protection Status

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Weather
    • Sport
    • Technology
    • Business & Finance
      • Currency Zone
    • Lotto Results
      • The Lott
  • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
    • Horoscopes
    • Health & Wellness
    • Recipes
  • Travel
  • Expat Life
  • Move to Australia

Copyright © Blue Sky Publications Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
australiantimes.co.uk is a division of Blue Sky Publications Ltd. Reproduction without permission prohibited. DMCA.com Protection Status